The Restaurant Guide for Wine Lovers
The Selkirk Arms Hotel
We assessed The Selkirk Arms Hotel in July 2026 and this review is based on the food menu and wine list at the time of the review. As menus and wine lists change, we name styles in order for the information to remain more useful as menus change. If things have slipped you can use the Vinealto Dining app including accessing an up to date reading using 'At the Table' from the wine list in front of you in the restaurant. How we assess
The Selkirk Arms is a harbour-town hotel bistro in Kirkcudbright serving a daily-changing menu of Scottish and international plates. Its wine list is a compact, supplier-led selection that covers the food competently and reaches up to a few genuinely good bottles, let down mainly by a thin sparkling shelf and by offering no pairing guidance for its own cured-fish plates. It will suit the traveller or local who wants an honest glass without study, and rewards the wine lover who arrives already knowing to ask for something unoaked and high in acid.
The full assessment of the wine programme, the pairings and how to get the best experience is for members. Make a free account to read five full entries.
Already have an account? Sign inMore in Dumfries and Galloway
The Black Bull Inn
Moffat, Dumfries and Galloway
Gastropub
The Black Bull Inn is a Scottish coaching inn in Moffat serving hearty comfort food (haggis, chilli, ribs, pies and burgers) with more of a wine list than the menu lets on. Behind the playful tasting notes sits a well-organised, glass-heavy list with genuine quality dotted through it and unusually generous pours, even if nothing steers the diner to a match and the sweet end is bare. It will suit anyone who wants a good, affordable glass with honest pub cooking, and who enjoys a list that does not take itself too seriously.
Read the assessmentCasa Mia
Dumfries, Dumfries and Galloway
Contemporary European, Italian-influenced
Casa Mia is a friendly modern European restaurant by the River Nith in Dumfries, with an Italian accent, a char grill and a few Asian touches. Its long list of more than a hundred wines from eleven countries is fairly priced, with fifteen by the glass at a quarter of the bottle price, though it offers little guidance. It will suit anyone who wants a wide choice of wine at fair prices with a relaxed dinner.
Read the assessmentThe Back Street
Dumfries, Dumfries and Galloway
Modern British
The Back Street is a relaxed modern British restaurant in the centre of Dumfries, cooking burgers, steaks and seafood with a few Asian touches. Its single page wine list is short, fairly priced and wider in range than most, though it offers few wines by the glass and no guidance on what to drink with what. It suits diners who are happy to share a bottle and pick their own match at a fair price.
Read the assessment