Risotto asparagus

Asparagus risotto — green or white asparagus cooked into the rice, finished with butter and Parmesan. Asparagus is one of the most wine-hostile vegetables: it contains mercaptans and asparagusic acid that make most wines taste metallic, sweeter than they are, or simply wrong. White asparagus is gentler than green; green is the greater challenge. The wine must have high acidity to sit above the asparagus compounds, no oak, no tannin, and enough body to carry the butter and Parmesan.

Pairs Perfectly

Grüner Veltliner in a medium-weight style — a Kamptal or Kremstal expression — lime-citrus, white pepper, mineral, moderate body, bone-dry. The white pepper character is one of the few aromatic compounds that engages asparagus rather than clashing with it, and the high acidity sits above the asparagus compounds without being stripped. The most analytically consistent answer for asparagus across all preparations.

Pairs Well

Verdicchio dei Castelli di Jesi, Marche, Italy — lean, high acid, slight bitter almond finish. The bitterness mirrors the asparagus character and the acidity cuts the butter and Parmesan without adding aromatic weight that would fight the vegetable compounds.

Sancerre blanc, Loire Valley, France — Sauvignon Blanc at its most mineral. The grassiness and gooseberry character engage asparagus from a complementary angle and the acidity sits above the compounds cleanly.

Avoid

Oaked wines of any colour — oak and asparagus compounds produce an immediately unpleasant metallic note. Tannic reds are entirely out of place.

Failing That

A dry Riesling from Alsace, France.

If All Else Fails

A Pinot Grigio from northern Italy.

Want to be able to craft answers like this? The Vinealto Wine Coach takes you from the basics to advanced.