VINEALTO™
English
English More languages coming soon

← Back to the Guide

The Restaurant Guide for Wine Lovers

Burts Hotel

66/100
  • Melrose, Scottish Borders
  • Modern Scottish
  • Mid-range, with a fine-wine cellar
  • Beta
What's this?

These are confidence labels — how sure we are that what we publish still reflects the restaurant's current practice. They are not a judgement on the restaurant; the wine and cooking are scored separately, out of 100.

  • Beta — assessed and scored, but we are still confirming some details (such as the current wine list), so it is published with that caveat.
  • No label — a fully confirmed entry.
  • In development — not yet a review; it appears so you can see where coverage is coming.

Some restaurants change their menus often, and we cannot always keep pace. Even so, our review stands as a point-in-time assessment — it can help you decide whether to visit, and it sets out the principles of pairing wine here, which should serve you whatever is on the list when you go. If things have moved on, the Vinealto pairing app can give you up-to-date advice on the spot.

Burts Hotel is a long-standing Borders coaching inn serving settled Scottish-French cooking across a bistro and a restaurant menu. Its wine programme earns its standing on a classic, merchant-supplied cellar with genuine claret and white-Burgundy depth and real maturity, let down by an absent by-the-glass offer and no dessert or fortified wine to close a meal. It will most reward the traditional drinker who wants a well-chosen bottle of Bordeaux or a crisp white with Scottish beef and fish, and is happy to drink by the bottle.

The full assessment — the wine programme, the pairings that lift a plate, and how the room reads for a wine lover — is for subscribers.

Subscribe for full access

More in Scottish Borders

63/100 Beta

Provender

Melrose, Scottish Borders

Modern Scottish and French

Provender is a Border town dining room cooking a seasonal modern Scottish and French menu from an excellent Scottish larder. Its wine programme earns its place on a broad, keenly-poured by-the-glass offer and a compact, intelligently chosen list that lets a table drink a glass to each course, let down only by the gaps a fuller list would close — no dessert or fortified wine for the puddings, and no printed pairings to point the way. It will most reward the diner who likes to drink by the glass across a meal and wants a considered, unfussy list to do it from.

  • By the glass
  • Mid-range
Read the assessment
56/100 Beta

The Townhouse

Melrose, Scottish Borders

Modern British brasserie

The Townhouse is a Borders hotel brasserie and restaurant cooking a seasonal modern British menu from good Scottish produce across two rooms. Its wine programme is a traditional bottle list with a genuine and gently-priced Bordeaux heart, let down for a wine lover only by the lack of a by-the-glass offer and a little looseness in how it is kept. It will most reward the diner who is happy to choose a bottle for the table and knows to look to the clarets, where the list is at its most serious and its best value.

  • Mid-range
Read the assessment

Back to the Guide